Rent vs buy calculator

Compare the total cost of renting with the net cost of buying a home over the years you plan to stay.

Last updated: November 2026 · Free estimates, no sign-up

What a rent vs buy calculator does

The rent vs buy decision is one of the biggest money choices most people make. A rent vs buy calculator compares the total cost of renting a home with the net cost of buying one over the years you expect to stay. It does not just compare a rent payment with a mortgage payment, because owning has other costs and also builds wealth through the loan paydown and any rise in the home’s value.

How to use this rent vs buy calculator

  1. Enter the price of the home you would buy and the mortgage rate you expect.
  2. Enter the monthly rent of a similar home.
  3. Enter how many years you plan to stay.
  4. Press Calculate to see which option costs less over that time.

To keep the tool simple, it assumes a 20% down payment, a 30-year loan, 3% yearly home price growth, 3% yearly rent growth and 2% of the home price a year for tax, insurance and upkeep.

How the comparison works

Net cost of buying = down payment + mortgage payments + tax, insurance and upkeep − (home value − loan balance)

Buying costs include your down payment, every mortgage payment during your stay and yearly ownership costs. When you sell, you recover the home’s value minus what you still owe, which reduces the net cost. Renting costs include all rent paid, with yearly increases. The calculator compares the two totals.

Worked example

A $350,000 home at a 6.5% mortgage rate, compared with rent of $2,000 a month and a stay of 7 years, using the built-in assumptions of a 20% down payment, a 30-year loan, 3% yearly home price growth, 3% yearly rent growth and 2% yearly ownership costs. Result: buying is cheaper by $93,527. The net cost of buying is about $90,372 and the total cost of renting is about $183,899.

How long you stay changes the answer

Using the same example with different stay lengths:

Years you stayResult
2 yearsBuying is cheaper: $20,029
3 yearsBuying is cheaper: $31,955
5 yearsBuying is cheaper: $59,867
7 yearsBuying is cheaper: $93,527
10 yearsBuying is cheaper: $155,756

Buying usually needs several years to pay off, because early payments are mostly interest and you pay costs to buy and eventually to sell.

Why the assumptions matter

Home prices do not always rise, and rents do not always grow at 3%. If prices in your area are flat or falling, buying looks worse than the result above, and if rents are rising quickly it looks better. Treat the result as a starting point and compare it with real listings and rents near you.

The costs of buying a home

  • Down payment and closing costs, often a few percent of the price.
  • Mortgage interest, property tax and home insurance.
  • Maintenance and repairs, commonly estimated at around 1% of the home’s value a year.
  • HOA fees, if the home has them.
  • Costs of selling, such as agent fees, which this simple model does not include.

The costs of renting

Rent is the main cost, and it usually rises over time. Add renter’s insurance and moving costs. What you do not pay is maintenance, property tax or the risk of a drop in the home’s value. If you invest the money you would have used for a down payment, that growth is a benefit of renting that this calculator does not count.

A quick rule of thumb: the 5% rule

Some analysts estimate that the unrecoverable yearly cost of owning, including property tax, maintenance and the cost of the money tied up, is roughly 5% of the home’s value. Divide that by 12 for a monthly figure. For a $350,000 home, that is about $1,458 a month. If rent for a similar home is below that, renting may be cheaper. It is a rough guide, so use it only as a sense check.

Non-financial factors

Money is not the whole story. Buying can give stability and control over your home. Renting gives flexibility to move for work or family and avoids repair bills. Think about how sure you are of staying put, how much savings you would have left after buying, and how you feel about maintenance.

Common mistakes

The biggest error is comparing rent with the mortgage payment alone. Another is assuming prices always rise, or forgetting maintenance, tax and closing costs. People also stay in a home for fewer years than planned, which tips the balance toward renting.

Frequently asked questions

It depends on local prices and rents, how long you will stay and your finances. Run your own numbers above.

Often five years or more, because of buying and selling costs.

A rule of thumb that owning costs about 5% of the home’s value a year in unrecoverable costs. If rent is lower, renting may win.

Not exactly. Rent pays for housing, just as interest, tax and upkeep do for owners.

Down payment, closing costs, interest, tax, insurance and maintenance.

It lowers your loan and monthly payment but ties up more cash.

A common estimate is around 1% of the home’s value each year.

Your equity falls and buying can cost more than renting. Test a low growth rate.

It is a real benefit of renting. This calculator keeps the model simple and does not include it.

Compare rent with the full cost of owning, not just the mortgage payment.

Yes. Rates, prices and rents change, so rerun the numbers.

No. It is an estimate for planning.

Related articles

Related calculators

Note

This calculator gives estimates for general use. It is not financial or medical advice.

Rent vs buy calculator

Enter your numbers, then press Calculate.